9. Chemical Exposures
Chemical disasters are likely related to the industries in the area, but they could result from an act of terror. The signs and symptoms of a chemical exposure generally appear fairly quickly and lead to the ready identification of a hot zone. Once a hot zone is properly identified, make every attempt to prevent secondary contamination. Attempt to identify the toxic chemical(s) as quickly as possible. Also, identifying the state (solid, liquid, or gas) of the chemical can be extremely helpful. Other clues that can aid in the diagnosis is whether the chemical had a certain color, smell, or aftertaste. Table 2 exemplifies how chemical identification can be made by using simple human senses.
Table 2. Chemical detection. Making “sense”of chemical weapons
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Suffocating, pungent, acrid sweet |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Unpleasant sweet peach |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Mustard |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Dry urine |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Garlic |
| Taste |
Metallic |
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Garlic, fishy |
| Taste |
Tasteless |
| Sight |
Colorless |
| Smell |
Odorless |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Odorless |
| Taste |
Tasteless |
| Sight |
Yellow-green gas |
| Smell |
Bleach |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
Colorless gas or crystal form |
| Smell |
Bitter almonds (50% of the population is unable to detect this smell secondary to genetic polymorphism) |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
Colorless (persistent liquid) |
| Smell |
Sweet, musty, shellac-like or resembling peaches |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Sickly sweet smell |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Sweet, ether-like |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Choking, acrid sweet |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Strong, suffocating, “pickle-like” odor |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Dry urine |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Decaying horse radish |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Rotten eggs |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
Oily, colorless |
| Smell |
Geraniums |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Odorless, but natural gas has mercaptan added |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
Colorless |
| Smell |
Odorless (slightly sweet at higher concentrations) |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Dry urine |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Rotten cabbage |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
Yellow to brown, oily liquid or colorless (depending on agent) |
| Smell |
Garlic, horse radish, fishy, musty, soapy, fruity (depending on agent used) |
| Taste |
Mustard |
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Choking, acrid sweet |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Garlic, aromatic, ester-like, sulfur |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
White or colorless gas |
| Smell |
Corn, grass, or freshly mowed hay |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Garlic, fishy |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
Luminescent glow |
| Smell |
Garlic |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Slight camphor odor, some describe as fruity |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Odor of “just-struck matches” |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
|
| Smell |
Faint fruity odor |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
Colorless |
| Smell |
Aromatic, sweet odor like benzene |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
Pale, yellow liquid |
| Smell |
Bleach, sharp pungent odor |
| Taste |
|
| Sight |
Colorless |
| Smell |
Odorless |
| Taste |
|
Modified from: “Chemical Terrorism: Diagnosis and Treatment” poster produced by the American College of Emergency Physicians
The signs and symptoms of a chemical exposure generally appear fairly quickly and lead to the ready identification of a “hot zone”.
Time and place plus onset and type of symptoms help assess risk and development of a management plan. When the number of symptomatic individuals is limited, the tasks being performed during or shortly before the onset of illness may be the critical clue in determining the toxic exposure. Certain activities are likely to use specific chemicals and the identification of the victim’s activity around the time of illness onset can aid in the generation of a list of possible chemical exposures. Sources of a wide array of chemical exposures are listed in Tables 3 and 4.
Table 3. Common Sources for Chemical Exposures
| Source Category |
Chemical Agent(s) |
| Adhesives |
Acryl nitrile |
| Anticorrosives |
Hydrazines, Methylhydrazines |
| Cleaners/Disinfectants |
Chlorine |
| Detergents |
Ammonia |
| Dyes |
Acryl nitrile |
| Fertilizer |
Ammonia |
| Foam insulants |
Formaldehyde |
| Food |
Botulinum (especially honey and home-canned products) |
| Fungicide |
Formaldehyde |
| Fumigant |
Acrylonitrile Cyanide Ethylene oxide Phosphine |
| Germicide |
Formaldehyde |
| Glass etching |
Hydrogen fluoride |
| Medical instrument sterilization |
Ethylene oxide |
| Metal cleaners |
Nitric acid |
| Metal etching |
Nitric acid |
| Pesticides |
Allyl alcohol Ammonia Organophosphates |
| Photography |
Cyanide |
| Pools/Hot tubs |
Chlorine |
| Rust removers |
Hydrogen fluoride |
| Solvents |
Hydrazine, Methylhydrazine |
| Tissue Preservative |
Formaldehyde |
| Wounds |
Botulinum |
Table 4. Common Chemical Exposures in Manufacturing
| Manufacturing Industry / Process |
Chemical Agent(s) |
| Biocides |
Acrolein |
| Chlorine |
Chlorine Hydrogen chloride |
| Electronics |
Arsine Stibine |
| Electroplating |
Cyanide |
| Explosives |
Ammonia Nitric acid Nitrogen dioxide |
| Ethylene glycol synthesis |
Ethylene oxide |
| Fertilizer |
Nitric acid |
| Fluorides and fluorocarbons |
Fluorine |
| Fuels |
Acrolein |
| Fungicides |
Methyl mercaptan |
| Glass |
Hydrogen selenide |
| Gun powder |
Nitric acid |
| Metal refining |
Hydrogen chloride |
| Mineral extraction |
Cyanide |
| Papers |
Cyanide Formaldehyde |
| Perfumes |
Allyl alcohol |
| Pesticides |
Methyl isocyanate Methyl mercaptan |
| Pharmaceuticals |
Acrolein |
| Plastics |
Allyl alcohol Cyanide Hydrogen selenide |
| Resins |
Allyl alcohol |
| Rocket fuel |
Fluorine Hydrazine Methyl hydrazine Methyl mercaptan |
| Rocket propellants |
Diborane Ethylene oxide |
| Semiconductors |
Arsine Stibine Diborane Hydrogen fluoride Phosphine |
| Steel |
Hydrogen selenide |
| Synthetic rubber |
Acrolein Hydrogen chloride Hydrogen selenide |
| Textiles |
Acrolein Cyanide |
| Vinyl chloride |
Hydrogen chloride |
Matching a constellation of signs and symptoms with an associated syndrome can assist in the identification of the specific chemical exposure. Disaster scene responders should have proper resources available for chemical identification. If a Poison Control Center can be contacted, its personnel will be able to aid in exposure identification and subsequent treatment. Otherwise, provisions for other informational support will be required. For example, in the United States, other sources such as Chemtrec (a HAZMAT communication center) can be contacted 24 hours per day by telephone or Internet. The Internet is an extremely valuable tool in times of uncertainty (see “Suggested Reading” for additional website resources). Refer to the Appendix “Chemical Glossary” for further details regarding
specific chemicals and their treatments. As an example, a relatively common chemical exposure is discussed below.
Case 2.
You are on duty in a provincial hospital when EMS reports come in that a disaster has occurred on the outskirts of a major metropolitan area. Witnesses report that there was an explosion after two trains collided. A greenish yellow cloud of gas was released which initially passed over 25.000 houses.
Reports come in that hundreds of victims are unresponsive at the scene and others are being transported by buses and other vehicles to your emergency department (ED). Some are complaining of burning eyes, profuse lacrimation, blepharospasm, and eyelid edema. Some are reporting blindness. Hundreds are having trouble breathing and present with cough. Emergency personnel and lay volunteers are attempting to supply wet face cloths to individuals, but are being attacked themselves by confused and distressed victims.
The first 75 victims arrive via buses and a few ambulances with 4 or 5 individuals inside receiving oxygen by face mask. They are coughing, wheezing and holding their eyes asking for help.
- What is your role in this crisis?
- Where do you report?
- What is the potential toxic gas that has been released in the incident?
- What simple yet lifesaving techniques should you be prepared to deliver?
- Was this an industrial accident or a terrorist event?
- How do you prepare for the victims care?
- What elements will you need for managing gas intoxicated victims?
Clinical Presentation of Chlorine Gas Intoxication
Chlorine gas is a strong irritant and may be corrosive to mucous membranes and eyes in concentrated amounts as occurs in industrial exposures. The severity of the exposure depends on different variables, including the concentration of the gas and the duration of the exposure. Despite the general belief, remember that the strength of the odor of the product is not a good indicator of the severity of the exposure. Table 5 shows the expected toxic effects according to the level of chlorine gas exposure.
Chlorine Exposure Levels and Toxic Effects
| Exposure Level (PPM) |
Toxic Effects |
| 0.5 ppm |
Chlorine gas is detectable in the air as a pungent odor. Chronic exposure to these limits may induce anosmia (loss of the sense of smell). |
| 1 ppm |
Symptoms include respiratory tract irritation, dryness and scratchiness of the throat, coughing and mild to moderate dyspnea. |
| 15 ppm |
Symptoms include severe dyspnea and violent headache. |
| 30 ppm |
Symptoms include intensive coughing, chest pain, nausea and vomiting, and shock. |
| 1,000 ppm |
Immediate death with a few breaths of this concentration. |
In chlorine gas exposure the presence of pre-existing cardiopulmonary disease and the water content of the involved tissues are specific factors that determine the severity of the exposure. In serious exposures, severe pulmonary irritation, pulmonary edema, and death may present quite rapidly. Survivors of severe exposures may develop residual pulmonary dysfunction, such as reactive airway disease and low residual volumes. Corrosion is not likely with the concentrations liberated in accidental home production when mixing bleach with an acid-containing cleaner (e.g., usually <1 parts per million [ppm]). A level of 1 ppm, however, is often used as a 15-minute short-term exposure level (STEL) for chlorine for occupational health purposes. Minor exposures usually result in mild burning sensation in the chest, coughing, lacrimation, and tachycardia. Minor exposures in the home may require no treatment other than removal from the exposure with resolution of the symptoms occurring within 1 to 6 hours. Those patients with persistent symptoms or chronic lung problems may require further evaluation and treatment. In some patients, symptoms may be delayed for up to several hours after exposure to chlorine gas. See Appendix for more information regarding the timing of onset of signs and symptoms for different toxic exposures.